Question 1

How do I find a Medicare broker in Greater Cincinnati or Dayton?

Accepted Answer

Look for an independent broker who is licensed in Ohio, represents multiple carriers, and will show you filed rates side by side. MedicareYourself serves Greater Cincinnati, the Miami Valley, and all of Southwest Ohio by phone and video, and publishes the filed-rate data we quote from so you can check our math before we ever speak.

Question 2

Can I keep my Christ Hospital, UC Health, TriHealth, or Kettering doctors on Medicare?

Accepted Answer

With Original Medicare plus a Medigap plan, yes — The Christ Hospital, UC Health, TriHealth, Mercy Health, Kettering Health, Premier Health, and every other system that accepts Medicare will take your coverage, with no networks and no referrals. With a Medicare Advantage plan, it depends on that plan's network for that year, and Cincinnati and Dayton networks are often anchored to specific systems. If you split care between systems, Medigap removes the network question entirely.

Question 3

I live in Cincinnati but some of my doctors are in Kentucky. Does that matter?

Accepted Answer

Not with Medigap. Greater Cincinnati care routinely crosses the river — St. Elizabeth Healthcare in Northern Kentucky is part of many residents' care — and a Medigap plan works with any provider in any state that accepts Original Medicare. With Medicare Advantage, cross-state coverage depends on the plan's network, so tri-state residents should check carefully before enrolling. It's one of the first things we verify.

Question 4

Are Medigap rates different in Cincinnati or Dayton than elsewhere in Ohio?

Accepted Answer

They can be. Ohio Medigap carriers price by rating area, so Hamilton or Montgomery County ZIPs can differ from our published Cleveland-sample table. The pattern that never changes is the spread — Ohio has the widest gap we track between the cheapest and most expensive carrier for identical benefits, in every rating area.

Question 5

When should Southwest Ohio residents apply for Medigap?

Accepted Answer

Ideally about six months before your Part B start date — applying early locks in your rate and prevents any coverage gap. Your Medigap Open Enrollment Period runs for six months once you're 65 or older and enrolled in Part B; during that window carriers must accept you regardless of health history. Outside that window, federal guaranteed-issue rights apply in specific situations, and several carriers accept applications with medical underwriting.

Question 6

What free Medicare help does Ohio offer?

Accepted Answer

OSHIIP — the Ohio Senior Health Insurance Information Program, run by the Ohio Department of Insurance — offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling at 1-800-686-1578. MedicareYourself works alongside OSHIIP by adding multi-carrier filed-rate comparisons and enrollment help.

Plan	Lowest filed rate	Highest filed rate	Carriers quoting
Plan G	$118/mo	$343/mo	32
Plan N	$102/mo	$277/mo	31

Medicare Broker for Greater Cincinnati & Dayton

What Medigap costs in Ohio right now

Why being tri-state-aware matters in Greater Cincinnati

Serving all of Southwest Ohio

Frequently Asked Questions

Go deeper on Ohio Medicare