Bankers Fidelity Stopped Selling in Texas and Colorado. Keep Your Policy or Switch?
By Anthony Orner, Independent Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker · NPN 20586791 · Filed rates pulled November 10, 2026 · Source: CSG Actuarial
Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company, the insurer behind Bankers Fidelity Medicare Supplement in Texas and Colorado, stopped taking new applications there. Its rate for new buyers ended November 6, 2026 in CSG Actuarial's rate data.
If you already have the policy, your coverage doesn't change. Medigap is guaranteed renewable, so the company can't cancel it while you pay the premium. What changes is the group your premium is priced on. From here on, nobody new joins it.
The question I'm hearing is whether to leave now. The honest answer depends on two things: your health today, and how your premium compares with what the same Plan G costs from a company still selling.
Carriers pay the broker. Your premium is the state-filed rate either way.
What a Closed Block Is (Agents Call It a Dead Pool)
A Medigap premium is priced on a group: everyone who bought the same policy from the same company in your state. Insurers call it a block. While the company is selling, new people join every month. Many are new to Medicare, and the rest just passed health questions to switch in, so they keep the group's average claims down.
When sales stop, the block is closed. Nobody joins. Everyone in it is a year older each year. And the people who can leave are the healthy ones, because they can pass another company's health questions. Those who stay tend to file more claims.
Medigap premiums are set to follow claims. That's the spiral agents mean by a dead pool: higher claims, a rate increase, more healthy people leaving, then higher claims again.
What the Latest Numbers Say
The spiral is a tendency, not a schedule. In May 2026, CSG Actuarial, the rate service we license, compared filed increases on open and closed blocks. In 2025 they ran close: 10.75% on closed blocks against 10% on open ones. In 2026 filings through May, open blocks ran higher, averaging 14% against 11% for closed blocks.
Closed blocks did pay out more of each premium dollar in claims: a loss ratio of 86.8% against 85.1% for open blocks, from NAIC data cited in a second CSG article the same month. That's the pressure the spiral starts from.
Those are market-wide averages across many carriers. Atlantic Capital's block is young: CSG lists the company as established in 2023. In Texas its Medicare Supplement grew from 871 covered lives in 2024 to 6,099 in 2025, and its loss ratio went from 52% to 73% (CSG Actuarial state market data). We have no Colorado count. A block that young has had little time to show its claims. What happens to your premium will show up in your renewal letter first.
What We've Seen Happen in the Same Family
Bankers Fidelity's older companies show how far an older book's price can sit from the rest of the market. These aren't closed blocks: they're still sold. What they show is where years of filings can leave a price.
| State | Company | Plan G @ 65 | Rank | Over the cheapest | Filed changes on record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oklahoma | Bankers Fidelity Assurance | $242.21 | 26 of 26 | $108.09/mo | +150.9% since 2017 (7 rate changes) |
| Montana | Bankers Fidelity Life | $370.00 | 22 of 22 | $227.85/mo | +218.3% since 2017 (9 rate changes) |
| Tennessee | Bankers Fidelity Assurance | $238.45 | 27 of 28 | $93.26/mo | +135.9% since 2017 (9 rate changes) |
| West Virginia | Bankers Fidelity Assurance | $205.64 | 21 of 25 | $80.32/mo | +113.3% since 2017 (10 rate changes) |
| Wyoming | Bankers Fidelity Life | $268.19 | 15 of 18 | $130.43/mo | +179.7% since 2016 (9 rate changes) |
| Michigan | Bankers Fidelity Assurance | $225.66 | 20 of 27 | $112.18/mo | +54.9% since 2021 (6 rate changes) |
| Iowa | Bankers Fidelity Assurance | $189.25 | 18 of 27 | $55.05/mo | +84.8% since 2022 (5 rate changes) |
Female, 65, non-tobacco, flagship county, CSG Actuarial licensed filings, pulled September 10, 2026 to September 14, 2026. Filed changes are compounded; a row that looks like a restatement, and the decrease that offsets it, are left out.
On those older books, filed changes add up to +54.9% to +218.3%. Atlantic Capital's newer policies, in the 9 states where it still sells, run +6.9% to +23.1%, and it files the cheapest Plan G in 8 of them. The older records start in 2016 to 2022; Atlantic Capital's start in 2024 to 2026, so they cover far fewer years. None of this predicts Atlantic Capital's next filing.
Should You Switch? How I'd Decide
Staying makes sense if
- Your health has changed since you bought it, in a way a health question would ask about.
- Your premium is still well under the prices below for the same plan letter.
- You'd rather see the next renewal letter first. Nothing forces a decision today.
Pricing a switch now makes sense if
- You're healthy today. Passing health questions is what lets you move, and it can change.
- A Plan G from a company still selling costs about what you pay now.
- You expect to keep a Medigap policy for many years.
In Texas and Colorado, moving after your first six months on Part B means answering the new company's health questions, unless a federal guaranteed-issue situation applies. A company closing its block isn't one.
- 1
Price the same plan letter. Plan G is Plan G at every company; the benefits are set by federal law. Compare your bill with the table below.
- 2
Apply before you cancel anything. Keep paying Atlantic Capital until the new company approves you and gives you a start date.
- 3
Use the 30-day free look. Federal rules give you 30 days with the new policy to decide. You pay both premiums for that month.
- 4
Cancel the old policy in writing once you've decided to keep the new one, inside the 30-day free look.
Plan G at 65 Today in Texas and Colorado
The cheapest Plan G filings from companies still selling, at 65 in each state's flagship county. Your own price is on your Atlantic Capital bill; at an older age every row here moves up too.
Texas (Harris County)
| Company | Plan G @ 65 | We can help you apply |
|---|---|---|
| New Era Life | $168.24 | Ask us |
| MedMutual Protect | $174.04 | Ask us |
| AARP / UnitedHealthcare | $176.73 | Ask us |
| Blue Cross Blue Shield | $177.03 | Ask us |
| LifeShield National | $177.35 | Yes |
| Washington National | $182.38 | Ask us |
25 companies on the board · pulled November 10, 2026
Colorado (Denver County)
| Company | Plan G @ 65 | We can help you apply |
|---|---|---|
| LifeShield National | $159.70 | Yes |
| Old Surety Life | $169.56 | Not through us |
| Washington National | $174.66 | Ask us |
| Insurance Company of North America (Chubb) | $179.83 | Yes |
| Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield | $181.24 | Ask us |
| WoodmenLife | $181.28 | Ask us |
24 companies on the board · pulled November 10, 2026
Bankers Fidelity Policyholder Questions
Have your renewal letter or your last bill handy. Read me the monthly premium and your date of birth, and I'll tell you where it sits against every Plan G filed at your ZIP, and whether the health questions are worth answering.
Call About My Bankers Fidelity Policy — 855-559-1700Data sources & methodology. Rates, ranks and filings are read at build time from CSG Actuarial licensed state files: Texas and Colorado pulled November 10, 2026, and the older-company table pulled September 10, 2026 to September 14, 2026. Each company is matched by NAIC. Premiums are for a female, age 65, non-tobacco applicant, individual rate as filed, at one sample ZIP in each state's flagship county. That Atlantic Capital stopped taking new applications in Texas and Colorado was confirmed on November 9, 2026 by Anthony Orner, an appointed agent with the carrier; the end of its new-business rate is from CSG quotes for December 2026 and January 2027 starts. Covered lives and loss ratios are CSG Actuarial state market data. Open and closed block figures are from CSG Actuarial's articles “Open Block vs. Closed Block: Med Supp Rate Changes in 2025 & 2026” and “The Closed Block Isn't Closed to Change,” May 2026.
Disclosure. This page is published by MedicareYourself, a brand of EasyKind Medicare, a licensed independent Medicare insurance broker. We are not Bankers Fidelity or Atlantic Capital and do not speak for either. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to the plans we offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to get information on all of your options.
Anthony Orner, NPN 20586791, 1309 Route 70 West, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002, 855-559-1700. Medicare has neither reviewed nor endorsed this information. 2026 Medicare figures: Part B premium $202.90/month, Part B deductible $283, Part A deductible $1,736.