MedicareYourself

North Carolina Medicare Supplement Pricing for Ages 65–69 (2026)

By Anthony Orner, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker

Verified against CSG Actuarial rate filings · Updated 2026-07-12 · Sample ZIP 28202, Charlotte

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) benefits are set by federal law — a Plan G from any licensed North Carolina carrier covers the exact same services as Plan G from any other carrier, at the same doctors and hospitals, with the same claims process. What differs is the monthly premium, the rate-increase history, and the discounts each carrier offers. This page shows the 2026 spread across every licensed carrier in North Carolina for ages 65, 67, and 69.

2026 NC Plan G Spread

$102 to $341/month across 29 carriers

A $239/month gap between the cheapest and most expensive Plan G in North Carolina — for coverage that is federally identical. Over 20 years of Medigap enrollment, that gap compounds into six figures of preventable spending.

Plan G Premium Spread by Age

Plan G is the most comprehensive plan available to anyone newly eligible for Medicare in 2026 — it covers everything Original Medicare leaves behind except the annual Part B deductible ($283). The table below shows the monthly premium spread across every licensed Plan G carrier in North Carolina for ages 65, 67, and 69.

AgeLowestHighestSpreadCarriers
Plan G, age 65$102/mo$315/mo$213/mo29
Plan G, age 67$102/mo$321/mo$219/mo29
Plan G, age 69$104/mo$341/mo$237/mo29

Source: CSG Actuarial rate filings, 2026-07-12. Sample ZIP 28202, Charlotte; your exact quote depends on your own ZIP, age, and health profile.

See the full carrier-by-carrier breakdown

Every licensed NC Medigap carrier, every discount you qualify for, every rate-increase history — in one phone call. No cost.

Call for NC Carrier Comparison — 855-559-1700

Plan N Premium Spread by Age

Plan N trades a lower premium for small copays (up to $20 per office visit and up to $50 per ER visit) and does not cover Part B excess charges. For enrollees who rarely see specialists and whose providers do not charge excess fees, Plan N is frequently the best monthly value in the North Carolina market.

AgeLowestHighestSpreadCarriers
Plan N, age 65$79/mo$262/mo$183/mo27
Plan N, age 67$79/mo$317/mo$238/mo27
Plan N, age 69$80/mo$348/mo$268/mo27

Source: CSG Actuarial rate filings, 2026-07-12. Sample ZIP 28202, Charlotte.

Why the Price Gap Is So Wide in North Carolina

North Carolina does not mandate a single Medigap pricing methodology, and the mix of approaches is the single biggest driver of the premium spread:

Because these methodologies coexist in North Carolina, the 2026 Plan G premium for a single 67-year-old enrollee can differ by more than $200 a month depending solely on which carrier issued the policy. A broker can show you not just today's rates but each carrier's pricing methodology and historical rate-adjustment pattern.

Named-Carrier Filed Rates (Plan G, age 65)

From our published carrier reviews — filed rate, market rank among 29 North Carolina carriers, and each carrier's most recent NC rate filing:

CarrierFiled Plan G (65)Market rankLatest NC filing
Bankers Fidelity$101.841 of 29+4.9% (2025-08-01)
Insurance Co of North America (Chubb)$126.194 of 29
Medico$128.015 of 29+18.59% (2025-09-01)
WoodmenLife$152.6613 of 29+15% (2026-01-15)
Mutual of Omaha$184.6425 of 29+20% (2026-05-01)

Rank and price change as new filings land — Mutual of Omaha's North Carolina block, for example, filed +25.01% effective April 2025 and then +20% effective May 2026. For the current cheapest carrier at your exact ZIP and age, call us — we quote every filed carrier, not a marketing shortlist.

The Household Discount Most NC Applicants Miss

6 of the licensed NC Plan G carriers offer a household discount, ranging from 11.1% to 20% off the standard monthly premium. Eligibility rules vary by carrier: some require marriage, some accept cohabitation, and some only require another adult in the household to have (or be applying for) Medigap coverage with any carrier.

Because the eligibility rules differ carrier by carrier, this discount is routinely missed by applicants going direct to a single insurer's website. It can change which carrier is actually cheapest for a couple.

Tobacco Rating in North Carolina

Unlike New Jersey — which prohibits tobacco rate differentials during the Medigap Open Enrollment Period — North Carolina carriers routinely file separate tobacco rates. In the current CSG snapshot, 38 of 38 NC carriers quoting this profile apply a tobacco surcharge, starting at 10% and averaging roughly 31.6% over the non-tobacco rate — with the steepest filed surcharge reaching 221%.

The practical takeaway: if you use tobacco, the carrier ranking changes. The cheapest non-tobacco Plan G in North Carolina is often not the cheapest tobacco-rated Plan G, and the difference between carriers' tobacco surcharges can run into hundreds of dollars a year. This is exactly the kind of filing-level detail a single carrier's website will never show you.

Get your ZIP-specific quote in one call

These tables are sample rates. Call to see every licensed carrier at your exact age, your ZIP, with every discount you qualify for.

Call for NC Quote — 855-559-1700

North Carolina Medigap Pricing FAQ

Ready to compare carriers?

Every NC-licensed carrier, every discount, every rate-increase history — in one phone call. Free to you.

Start Your NC Comparison — 855-559-1700

Data source & methodology

Premium spreads on this page are pulled from the CSG Actuarial rate-filing database — the same source licensed Medigap brokers use to compare carriers. The snapshot reflects sample-ZIP rates for female applicants, non-tobacco, at ages 65, 67, and 69 in Charlotte. These are sample rates, not your personal quote; call for your ZIP-specific rate.

Anthony Orner, NPN 20586791, 1309 Route 70 West, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002, 855-559-1700, licensed in New Jersey and 34 other states. MedicareYourself (EasyKind Medicare) is an independent brokerage. We are not affiliated with Medicare, CMS, or any insurance carrier.