MedicareYourself

Turning 65 in Indiana: Medigap Open Enrollment and the Birthday Rule

By Anthony Orner, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker · Rates: CSG Actuarial, pulled September 11, 2026

In Marion County, the cheapest Plan G for a 65-year-old is $118.22 a month, from Bankers Fidelity (Atlantic Capital Life). Plan N starts at $85.00 there. 27 companies file Plan G in Indiana.

Indiana adds a twist most states don't have. Since 2026, a birthday rule lets you change companies later. It doesn't let you change plan letters.

Check your Indiana price and apply →

Your ZIP and birthday give your rate first. A licensed agent checks your answers before the company sees them, and the premium is what the company filed with Indiana.

At 65: open enrollment

For six months from the first month you're 65 and on Part B, any Indiana company must sell you any plan letter at its standard rate. You're in one of three spots:

Lowest Indiana Plan G filings at 65

CompanyPlan G at 65Plan N at 65Plan G at 70How the price moves with age
Bankers Fidelity (Atlantic Capital Life)from $118.22$91.57$124.20Rises as you age
Members Health$130.00$85.00$143.50Rises as you age
LifeShield National$138.86$103.73$143.80Rises as you age
HealthSpring Insurance (HCSC)from $139.19$89.20$173.71Rises as you age
American Benefit Life$156.54$117.07$161.00Rises as you age
Medico Insurance Companyfrom $157.69$111.31$159.27Rises as you age

Monthly rates for Marion County (ZIP 46239), the 6 lowest Plan G filings (each company's lowest rate class) at 65 of 27 companies. Female, non-tobacco, no household discount. Source: CSG Actuarial, pulled September 11, 2026. Your ZIP can differ.

After 65: Indiana's birthday rule

Indiana's law (HEA 1226 of 2025) took effect January 1, 2026. Once you're 65 or older with a Medigap policy, you can move to the same plan letter at another company each year. No health questions and no denial. The window opens one month before your birthday and closes one month after. The new policy starts the first of the month after you sign.

So at 65 the company is a choice you can revisit, and the letter mostly isn't. A move from Plan N to Plan G later means health questions. Pick the letter you want to keep: Plan G pays everything but the Part B deductible, and Plan N trades a lower premium for small copays.

How early you can apply

Before Part B, in most cases. Most companies take your application ahead of time so coverage begins with Part B; Mutual of Omaha and Chubb go as far as six months before the month you turn 65. Applying early can lock in the rate on file today. The application table has each company's window; the Indiana rate index has every county.

Turning 65 in Indiana? Talk to a Licensed Broker — 855-559-1700

Turning 65 in Indiana: Questions

Sources. Indiana rates: CSG Actuarial, pulled September 11, 2026; female, non-tobacco, individual rates. Birthday rule: Indiana Department of Insurance fact sheet on HEA 1226 (amended by HEA 1260 for policies from March 15, 2026). Open enrollment and guaranteed issue: federal rules at Medicare.gov.

Disclosure. MedicareYourself is a brand of EasyKind Medicare, a licensed independent Medicare insurance broker. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048) for information on all of your options.

Questions about Indiana Medigap? Call us — 855-559-1700