Apply for a Medicare Supplement Online: Company by Company
By Anthony Orner, Independent Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker · NPN 20586791 · Company websites checked November 10, 2026 · Filed rates pulled September 10, 2026 to November 20, 2026 · Source: CSG Actuarial
4 of the 10 Medicare Supplement companies below take a consumer application on their own website. The other 6 take applications by phone or through licensed agents. Medicare.gov takes none: it lists companies and can't enroll anyone in a Medigap policy.
Our online application takes 8 of them from one ZIP and birthday: Aetna, Mutual of Omaha, Chubb, Medico, Aflac, HealthSpring, Humana and Bankers Fidelity / Atlantic Capital Life. It opens six months before your 65th birthday and takes about 15 minutes. Applying early can lock in the rate on file today.
The insurance company pays the broker out of its state-filed rate. There's no fee to you.
Who Takes an Online Application
“Its own website” means a consumer can price a plan and apply there without an agent. A contact form or a quote request that an agent follows up doesn't count.
| Company | Apply on its own website | Our online application | Applying before 65 | Plan G at 65, range across states |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aetna Aetna review | No. aetna.com says to call to sign up for a Medicare Supplement. | Yes, apply online | Yes, before Part B starts (our applications) | $174.51 to $314.87 in 27 states |
| Mutual of Omaha Mutual of Omaha review | Yes. Quote and apply at mutualofomaha.com. Or apply on Mutual of Omaha's own site with us as your agent (you can call us with questions after you apply). | Yes, apply online | Up to six months before the month you turn 65 (agent guide) | $161.00 to $461.94 in 28 states |
| Chubb (Insurance Company of North America) How to apply for Chubb | No. Chubb's Medicare Supplement pages are logins for policyholders, agents and providers. | Yes, apply online | Up to six months before the month you turn 65 (agent guide) | $131.60 to $254.83 in 27 states |
| Medico (Wellabe) How to apply for Medico | No. wellabe.com offers a phone number and a request-a-call button. | Yes, apply online | Yes, before Part B starts (2016 agent guide) | $139.14 to $253.81 in 17 states |
| Aflac How to apply for Aflac | No. Its site takes a quote request. A licensed agent then calls and takes the application. | Yes, apply online | Yes, before Part B starts (our applications) | $151.64 to $255.10 in 27 states |
| HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) HealthSpring review | Yes. Shop and apply at healthspring.com, which advertises a 5% discount for applying there in most states. | Yes, apply online | Not confirmed. Ask us | $134.20 to $295.75 in 27 states |
| Humana Humana review | Yes. Shop at humana.com, which advertises 6% off for enrolling online in most states. | Yes, apply online | No. The application needs your Medicare number (our applications) | $134.56 to $376.43 in 27 states |
| AARP / UnitedHealthcare | Yes. Apply at uhc.com. You must be an AARP member to enroll. | It shows the price. Ask us about applying | Ask the company | $118.17 to $333.00 in 28 states |
| Bankers Fidelity / Atlantic Capital Life How to apply for Bankers Fidelity | No. Its site has a quote form that says an independent agent may call. | Yes, in the states where it still sells | Up to six months before the Part B start date (agent guide) | $114.30 to $242.21 in 16 states |
| LifeShield National How to apply for LifeShield | No. Its site has a contact form, not an application. | Not yet. We take it by phone | Ask us | $125.11 to $243.14 in 23 states |
Websites read November 10, 2026. “Agent guide” is the company's underwriting guide for agents; “our applications” is what this agency's own submissions get. Plan G: the lowest rate the brand files at 65 in each state's flagship county, across the 28 states on our rate boards (CSG Actuarial licensed filings, female, non-tobacco, pulled September 10, 2026 to November 20, 2026).
How Early You Can Apply
Two different clocks run here. Medicare's is the Medigap Open Enrollment Period: six months that start the month you're 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. In it, no company can turn you down or charge more for your health.
The second clock is each company's own. Many take an open-enrollment application months before Part B starts, with the coverage dated to begin when Part B does. Put together, that's about six months before and six months after: close to a year with no health questions.
The table shows each company's “before” half. Our online application opens six months before your 65th birthday. Humana is the exception: its application asks for your Medicare number, so it waits until you have one.
Applying early can lock in the rate on file today. Ask on the confirming call how that works for your start date.
What Happens When You Apply Online With Us
- 1
Your rate, in about 30 seconds. ZIP, birthday, sex and tobacco use. The price comes from the company's filed rate table, Plan G and Plan N side by side.
- 2
The application, about 15 minutes. Address, Medicare number if you have it, Part A and Part B start dates, and how you'd like to pay. You can stop and pick it up later on another device.
- 3
A licensed agent reviews it. The agent calls to confirm the details and fixes anything that would make the carrier return it. Then the application goes to you to sign.
- 4
The company issues the policy. It mails the policy, and the premium goes to the insurance company, never to the agency.
Where We Take Applications
We're licensed and take applications in 27 states: Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Montana, New Hampshire, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming. Not every company sells in every one.
The online application isn't available in Connecticut or New York, so Connecticut is by phone. Everywhere else, enter a ZIP and it shows the companies and plans it can take at that address. In a state where we aren't licensed yet, it still shows prices and takes a phone number, and we call once the license is in place.
In any state, your SHIP gives free counseling and sells nothing. Find it at shiphelp.org.
When the Company's Own Website Is the Better Door
- An online-enrollment discount applies where you live. Humana's site advertises 6% off the monthly premium for enrolling online, not offered in California, Connecticut, Ohio or Pennsylvania. HealthSpring's advertises 5% for an application submitted online at HealthSpring.com, not offered in Connecticut, D.C., Florida, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oregon or Vermont. Where one applies, ask us to price that company both ways before you pick.
- A direct-only rate is the lowest one. A few companies file a rate class sold only to people who apply without an agent. Which ones, and what going direct gives up.