MedicareYourself

MedMutual Protect Medigap Review: What It Costs and Where It Ranks

By Anthony Orner, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker · Data as of November 10, 2026

MedMutual Protect (MedMutual Life Insurance Company, NAIC 62375), part of the Medical Mutual of Ohio group, sells Plan G and Plan N Medigap in the 6 states below. As of November 10, 2026 CSG data, it files the cheapest Plan G on the board in Wyoming — but it is also the newest carrier on this page, writing Medigap here only since 2024, and 3 of its 6 states already carry two filed increases.

Compare MedMutual Protect to Every Carrier at Your ZIP →

Almost nothing independent has been written about MedMutual Protect's Medigap pricing. This review is built from filed premiums, price rank against every competing carrier, and rate-increase history — from the licensed broker who can actually place the policy.

"MedMutual Protect" Is a Brand Name, Not the Ohio Health Plan

Medical Mutual of Ohio is a familiar name to Ohio residents for employer and ACA health coverage, but the Medigap business on this page is a separate, newer product line: MedMutual Life Insurance Company (NAIC 62375) underwrites it, selling under the MedMutual Protect brand in Wyoming, Texas, Georgia, Virginia, Arkansas and Colorado. CSG's filed-rate data shows this entity writing Medigap in our licensed states only since 2024 — recent enough that none of its states has a second-year track record longer than two filings.

Check the entity on your paperwork. If a quote or medicare.gov listing names Medical Mutual of Ohio's general health-plan business rather than MedMutual Protect specifically, this review's rates and rating don't describe that product — call with your ZIP and I'll confirm which entity is actually quoting you.

MedMutual Protect Rates & Market Rank (Plan G @ 65, Female, Non-Tobacco)

StatePlan GG rankPlan NN rankRate basisLatest filing
Wyoming$137.761 of 18 — cheapest in Laramie County$95.371 of 18attained age+14.99% (October 1, 2025)
Texas$174.042 of 25$121.872 of 24attained age+16% (July 1, 2026)
Georgia$168.963 of 21$119.355 of 22issue age+15% (October 1, 2026)
Virginia$143.474 of 22$133.0711 of 22attained ageNone on file
Arkansas$193.385 of 24$141.524 of 24community rated+15% (October 1, 2026)
Colorado$189.7811 of 24$140.7712 of 21attained age+24% (October 1, 2026)

Source: CSG Actuarial licensed API as of November 10, 2026. Female 65, non-tobacco, individual rate as filed, quoted through one sample ZIP per rating area in each state's flagship county; rates in other ZIPs may differ.

Every carrier's Plan G pays the same federally standardized benefits, so price, rate basis and filing history are what actually separate them. MedMutual Protect's cheapest dollar premium and its best rank happen to be the same state — Wyoming, 1 of 18 filed carriers. Its highest dollar premium is Arkansas at $193.38, yet that only ranks 5 of 24 — Arkansas's whole board simply prices higher.

Why a MedMutual Protect Quote Behaves Differently From State to State

CSG's filed rate basis splits MedMutual Protect's footprint three ways. In 4 of the 6 states on this page — Wyoming, Texas, Virginia and Colorado — it prices Medigap on an attained-age basis: the premium rises every year or so you get older, on top of whatever percentage the company files for the whole block. Arkansas is community rated instead, so every policyholder pays the same price regardless of the age they bought the policy at. Georgia prices it issue-age: your premium is locked at the age you enrolled and only moves with a filed rate change, never with your birthday.

That split compounds with how young this block is. A buyer in an attained-age state pays two kinds of increase every year — MedMutual Protect's filed percentage, plus the age-based step the rate basis itself builds in — and this carrier has already filed two increases in most of its states within two years of entering them.

A Young Block's Early Filing Record

Texas shows the steepest Plan G climb on this board: a compounded 34.6% across its two filed increases (Plan N rose the same 34.6% there). Colorado tells a different story: its first filed increase was smaller, but a much larger second one compounds to the steepest Plan N climb on the board instead, 48.4%. Either way, that is two rate actions in two years for a carrier CSG's data shows writing Medigap in our footprint only since 2024. The steepest single 2026 filing on this board is 24%, in Colorado.

Virginia shows no filed Plan G increase for MedMutual Protect yet — the youngest filing on this board. A new-business rank only describes what a first-year buyer pays. If you already own a MedMutual Protect policy and your renewal letter just arrived, call and compare it against what a new application would cost today — outside a guaranteed-issue right, switching carriers means new health questions.

MedMutual Protect Plan N: How It Compares

Its strongest Plan N showing is Wyoming, 1 of 18 — the cheapest Plan N filing on the board in Wyoming. Plan N's board position here tracks Plan G closely rather than beating it outright, which is the opposite pattern from some newer entrants that undercut hardest on Plan N.

Plan N costs less than Plan G because you pay up to $20 at some office visits and up to $50 at the ER, plus any Part B excess charges the provider bills. On MedMutual Protect, that trade comes with the same early-filing rate climb its Plan G shows.

How to Apply for MedMutual Protect Medigap

You can compare the carriers you can apply with online at apply.medicareyourself.com, which takes about 15 minutes, or call 855-559-1700 and I'll read you the whole board, MedMutual Protect included.

Compare Carriers Online →

MedMutual Protect Medicare Supplement: Common Questions

Comparing more than one unfamiliar name on a quote? New Era Life's review and Old Surety Life's review cover two more carriers people often can't place.

Questions About MedMutual Protect? Talk to a Licensed Broker — 855-559-1700

Data sources & methodology. Plan G and Plan N rates, ranks and filed rate increases on this page are sourced from the CSG Actuarial API as of November 10, 2026, for a Female 65 non-tobacco applicant, one flagship county per state. The AM Best rating for Medical Mutual of Ohio Group is from medicalmutual.com; the Weiss Ratings grade for MedMutual Life Insurance Company (NAIC 62375) is from weissratings.com, dated July 2025. Verify both directly before relying on either.

Disclosure. This page is published by MedicareYourself, a brand of EasyKind Medicare. We are a licensed independent Medicare insurance broker. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to the plans we offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to get information on all of your options. Plan availability, plan letters, and premiums vary by state and are subject to state Department of Insurance rate filings.

Medicare has neither reviewed nor endorsed this information. 2026 Medicare figures: Part B premium $202.90/month, Part B deductible $283, Part A deductible $1,736.

Compare Medigap plan benefits on the official Medicare.gov Medigap guide and review standardized Medigap plan benefits before choosing a carrier.