Cheapest Medicare Supplement in Dallas: New Era Life Plan G at $152.95
By Anthony Orner, Independent Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker · Dallas filed rates pulled November 11, 2026, CSG Actuarial · ZIP 75201 (Downtown Dallas)
In downtown Dallas (ZIP 75201) the cheapest Plan G for a 65-year-old woman is New Era Life, $152.95 a month (CSG Actuarial, pulled November 11, 2026). That's $2.23 under the next company, MedMutual Protect.
The cheapest company here we can help you apply with is LifeShield National: $159.29, number 3 of 25. We aren't appointed with New Era Life. The gap is smallest in Denton: $3.44 a month. Give me your ZIP and I'll tell you where you land.
Insurers pay the broker. The filed premium doesn't change when you use one.
Downtown Dallas Plan G Board, 25 Companies
| # | Company | Monthly | Over #1 | AM Best | With us |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New Era Life | $152.95 | — | A- | — |
| 2 | MedMutual Protect | $155.18 | +$2.23 | — | — |
| 3 | LifeShield National | $159.29 | +$6.34 | B++ | We can help you apply |
| 4 | Blue Cross Blue Shield | $161.51 | +$8.56 | A+ | — |
| 5 | Insurance Company of North America (Chubb) | $165.75 | +$12.80 | A++ | We can help you apply |
| 6 | Plateau Insurance | $167.28 | +$14.33 | — | We can help you apply |
| 7 | Washington National | $167.77 | +$14.82 | A | — |
| 8 | Members Health | $168.69 | +$15.74 | — | — |
| 9 | AARP / UnitedHealthcare (Standard class) | $168.95 | +$16.00 | A | — |
| 10 | HealthSpring Insurance (HCSC) | $172.60 | +$19.65 | A | — |
| 11 | Nassau Life Insurance Company | $177.90 | +$24.95 | B++ | — |
| 12 | WoodmenLife | $179.44 | +$26.49 | A+ | — |
| 13 | Aflac (Tier One Insurance) | $180.41 | +$27.46 | A+ | We can help you apply |
| 14 | American Benefit Life | $186.47 | +$33.52 | A- | — |
| 15 | Old Surety Life | $188.41 | +$35.46 | — | — |
| 16 | State Farm | $188.87 | +$35.92 | A+ | — |
| 17 | United American | $189.00 | +$36.05 | A | We can help you apply |
| 18 | WPS Health Solutions | $193.64 | +$40.69 | — | — |
| 19 | Humana Insurance Company | $196.63 | +$43.68 | A | — |
| 20 | USAA Life | $198.73 | +$45.78 | A++ | — |
| 21 | Mutual of Omaha | $215.65 | +$62.70 | A+ | We can help you apply |
| 22 | Aetna Health Insurance | $225.99 | +$73.04 | A | — |
| 23 | Physicians Mutual | $239.60 | +$86.65 | A+ | We can help you apply |
| 24 | Guarantee Trust Life | $254.41 | +$101.46 | A | — |
| 25 | GPM Health and Life | $257.77 | +$104.82 | B++ | — |
CSG Actuarial filings pulled November 11, 2026, ZIP 75201, woman, 65, non-tobacco, individual, no household discount, each company's lowest rate class. Green: companies we're contracted with.
Plano, Frisco, Fort Worth and Denton
The same New Era Life Plan G costs $137.79 in Plano and $152.95 in Downtown Dallas. Nothing about the policy changes between them; the company prices by ZIP. Denton is where we come closest. LifeShield National is number 2 there at $141.22, $3.44 behind MedMutual Protect.
| Place (ZIP, county) | Cheapest Plan G | Cheapest we can help with |
|---|---|---|
| Downtown Dallas (75201, Dallas County) | $152.95 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| Plano (75074, Collin County) | $137.79 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| Frisco (75034, Collin County) | $137.79 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| Fort Worth (76102, Tarrant County) | $152.95 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| Denton (76201, Denton County) | $137.78 (MedMutual Protect) | $141.22 (LifeShield National, #2 of 25) |
One ZIP per place, same profile. #n ranks the company on that ZIP's board.
Dallas Plan G at 70, 75 and 80
New Era Life is the cheapest Plan G downtown at every age we priced. The cheapest company we can help you apply with does change: LifeShield National at 65 and 70, Insurance Company of North America (Chubb) at 75, Plateau Insurance at 80. Each row is today's price for a buyer of that age, not where a 65-year-old's policy lands later.
| Age | Cheapest Plan G | Cheapest we can help with | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 65 | $152.95 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3) | +$6.34 |
| 70 | $158.77 (New Era Life) | $164.95 (LifeShield National, #2) | +$6.18 |
| 75 | $183.58 (New Era Life) | $199.58 (Insurance Company of North America (Chubb), #3) | +$16.00 |
| 80 | $227.00 (New Era Life) | $231.56 (Plateau Insurance, #3) | +$4.56 |
ZIP 75201, woman, non-tobacco.
Rate Increases on the Top of the Board
- New Era Life: CSG's Texas record shows -37.4% on August 4, 2026. Don't read it as a price cut: it largely reversed a +98.42% December 2025 filing that our September 10, 2026 pull showed, a row CSG has since dropped. The New Era review has the detail.
- MedMutual Protect: filings of +16.0% in October 2025 and +16.0% in July 2026 since January 2025. CSG lists no AM Best rating.
- LifeShield National: filings of +13.0% in July 2025 and +17.3% in July 2026 since January 2025. AM Best B++.
The cheapest premium at 65 is where a policy starts. The filings are where it goes.
Downtown Dallas, Plano, Frisco, Fort Worth and Denton
The ZIP, not the city name, sets the price. Tell me your ZIP and birth date and I'll read the board for your address.
Get My DFW Prices — 855-559-1700Plan N in Dallas
The cheapest Plan N at 65 downtown is $105.35 from Washington National. The cheapest we can help you apply for is Plateau Insurance at $109.96, number 3, $4.61 behind. Plan N adds copays of up to $20 at the doctor's office and leaves Part B excess charges to you. Texas Plan G vs Plan N compares the two letters company by company.
Methodology
- Prices are filed rates from our licensed CSG Actuarial pull dated November 11, 2026, each quoted at the ZIP named beside it.
- Woman, 65 unless the table says otherwise, non-tobacco, individual, no household discount; the lowest filed rate class for each company.
- Left out: direct-to-consumer and guaranteed-issue classes, bundled Plan G variants, and anything over four times the board median.
- Green rows are the 8 Medigap companies we're contracted with, matched by NAIC code.
Anthony Orner, NPN 20586791, 1309 Route 70 West, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002, 855-559-1700, licensed in Texas and 33 other states. MedicareYourself (easyKind Medicare) is an independent brokerage, not affiliated with Medicare, CMS or any insurance company. We are contracted with some of the companies on this page and are not any of them.