Cheapest Medicare Supplement in San Antonio: Plan G From $152.95
By Anthony Orner, Independent Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker · San Antonio filed rates pulled November 11, 2026, CSG Actuarial · ZIP 78205 (Downtown San Antonio)
Downtown San Antonio's cheapest Plan G for a 65-year-old woman is New Era Life at $152.95 a month, in CSG Actuarial filings pulled November 11, 2026. Second is MedMutual Protect, $2.23 behind. Third is LifeShield National at $159.29.
Of those three, LifeShield National is the one we can help you apply with: number 3, $6.34 a month off the top. We aren't appointed with New Era Life.
Outside downtown the board moves. Helotes (78023) starts at $137.78 from MedMutual Protect, $15.17 under ZIP 78205. LifeShield National is number 3 there, $3.44 behind.
Insurers pay us, not you. The filed rate is the same either way.
All 25 Downtown San Antonio Plan G Companies
| # | Company | Monthly | Over #1 | AM Best | With us |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New Era Life | $152.95 | — | A- | — |
| 2 | MedMutual Protect | $155.18 | +$2.23 | — | — |
| 3 | LifeShield National | $159.29 | +$6.34 | B++ | We can help you apply |
| 4 | Members Health | $160.63 | +$7.68 | — | — |
| 5 | AARP / UnitedHealthcare (Standard class) | $162.85 | +$9.90 | A | — |
| 6 | Blue Cross Blue Shield | $163.50 | +$10.55 | A+ | — |
| 7 | Old Surety Life | $163.67 | +$10.72 | — | — |
| 8 | Insurance Company of North America (Chubb) | $165.75 | +$12.80 | A++ | We can help you apply |
| 9 | Plateau Insurance | $167.28 | +$14.33 | — | We can help you apply |
| 10 | Washington National | $167.77 | +$14.82 | A | — |
| 11 | WPS Health Solutions | $168.50 | +$15.55 | — | — |
| 12 | HealthSpring Insurance (HCSC) | $172.60 | +$19.65 | A | — |
| 13 | Humana Insurance Company | $174.67 | +$21.72 | A | — |
| 14 | Nassau Life Insurance Company | $177.90 | +$24.95 | B++ | — |
| 15 | WoodmenLife | $179.44 | +$26.49 | A+ | — |
| 16 | USAA Life | $180.88 | +$27.93 | A++ | — |
| 17 | American Benefit Life | $186.47 | +$33.52 | A- | — |
| 18 | Aflac (Tier One Insurance) | $188.52 | +$35.57 | A+ | We can help you apply |
| 19 | State Farm | $188.87 | +$35.92 | A+ | — |
| 20 | Mutual of Omaha | $215.65 | +$62.70 | A+ | We can help you apply |
| 21 | United American | $218.00 | +$65.05 | A | We can help you apply |
| 22 | Aetna Health Insurance | $225.99 | +$73.04 | A | — |
| 23 | Physicians Mutual | $227.62 | +$74.67 | A+ | We can help you apply |
| 24 | Guarantee Trust Life | $254.41 | +$101.46 | A | — |
| 25 | GPM Health and Life | $257.77 | +$104.82 | B++ | — |
CSG Actuarial filings pulled November 11, 2026, ZIP 78205; woman, 65, non-tobacco, individual, no household discount; lowest filed rate class per company. Green rows: companies we're contracted with.
The Top Three, Age by Age
The lead doesn't hold still. The cheapest is New Era Life at 65, 70 and 75, Old Surety Life at 80. LifeShield National moves up to number 2 at 70. A buyer at each age pays the row shown; someone who bought at 65 also carries every later filing.
| Company | Age 65 | Age 70 | Age 75 | Age 80 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New Era Life | $152.95 #1 | $158.77 #1 | $183.58 #1 | $227.00 #2 |
| MedMutual Protect | $155.18 #2 | $165.43 #3 | $194.12 #2 | $227.78 #3 |
| LifeShield National | $159.29 #3 | $164.95 #2 | $202.92 #6 | $249.38 #6 |
The three cheapest companies at 65, priced at each age. #n is the rank on the board at that age.
The Cheapest, and the Cheapest We Can Help With, at Each Age
| Age | Cheapest Plan G | Cheapest we can help with | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 65 | $152.95 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3) | +$6.34 |
| 70 | $158.77 (New Era Life) | $164.95 (LifeShield National, #2) | +$6.18 |
| 75 | $183.58 (New Era Life) | $199.58 (Insurance Company of North America (Chubb), #4) | +$16.00 |
| 80 | $223.75 (Old Surety Life) | $231.56 (Plateau Insurance, #4) | +$7.81 |
ZIP 78205, woman, non-tobacco.
What the Front-Runners Have Filed
The price at 65 is one number. How each company has raised its Plan G since is the other.
- New Era Life: a -37.4% filing on August 4, 2026 in CSG's Texas record. It largely reversed a +98.42% December 2025 filing that our September 10, 2026 pull showed (CSG has since dropped that row), so it isn't a price cut. Our New Era review explains it.
- MedMutual Protect: +16.0% in October 2025, then +16.0% in July 2026. No AM Best rating in CSG's data.
- LifeShield National: +13.0% in July 2025, then +17.3% in July 2026. AM Best B++.
Your ZIP decides which of these is cheapest for you
Give me your ZIP and birth date. I'll show the front-runners side by side at your age and tell you which ones we can help you apply with.
Compare the San Antonio Front-Runners — 855-559-1700Around San Antonio, ZIP by ZIP
| Place (ZIP, county) | Cheapest Plan G | Cheapest we can help with |
|---|---|---|
| Downtown San Antonio (78205, Bexar County) | $152.95 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| North San Antonio (78232, Bexar County) | $152.95 (New Era Life) | $159.29 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| Helotes (78023, Bexar County) | $137.78 (MedMutual Protect) | $141.22 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| New Braunfels (78130, Comal County) | $137.78 (MedMutual Protect) | $141.22 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
| Schertz (78154, Guadalupe County) | $137.78 (MedMutual Protect) | $141.22 (LifeShield National, #3 of 25) |
North San Antonio, Helotes, New Braunfels and Schertz quoted at one ZIP each, same profile. #n ranks the company on that ZIP's board.
Plan N in San Antonio
The cheapest Plan N at 65 downtown is $105.35 from Washington National. Among companies we're contracted with, Plateau Insurance is cheapest at $109.96 (number 3). See Plan G vs Plan N in Texas for the copay math.
Methodology
- Filed rates from our licensed CSG Actuarial pull dated November 11, 2026, each quoted at the ZIP shown; no price on the page is typed.
- Woman, 65 unless stated, non-tobacco, individual, no household discount; each company's lowest filed rate class. Men usually pay more.
- Excluded: direct-to-consumer and guaranteed-issue classes, bundled Plan G variants, rows above four times the board median.
- "We can help you apply" covers the 8 Medigap companies we're contracted with, by NAIC code.
Anthony Orner, NPN 20586791, 1309 Route 70 West, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002, 855-559-1700, licensed in Texas and 33 other states. MedicareYourself (easyKind Medicare) is an independent brokerage with no affiliation to Medicare, CMS or any insurer. We are contracted with some of the companies on this page and are not any of them.